| Pastor | Dates |
| Rev. Shubael Dummer | 1662 - 1692 |
| Rev. Samuel Moody | 1698 - 1747 |
| Rev. Isaac Lyman | 1749 - 1810 |
| Rev. Roswell Messinger | 1798 - 1813 |
| Rev. Moses Dow | 1815 - 1829 |
| Rev. Eber Carpenter | 1830 - 1835 |
| Rev. John Haven | 1836 - 1840 |
| Rev. John L. Ashby | 1841 - 1849 |
| Rev. William J. Newman | 1849 - 1850 |
| Rev. John Smith | 1850 - 1855 |
| Rev. William A. Patten | 1855 - 1858 |
| Rev. William W. Parker | 1858 - 1860 |
| Rev. Rufus M. Sawyer | 1861 - 1866 |
| Rev. John Parsons | 1866 - 1869 |
| Rev. Benjamin W Pond | 1870 - 1873 |
| Rev. David B. Sewall | 1873 -1888 |
| Rev. George M. Woodwell | 1890 - 1894 |
| Rev. Melvin J. Allen | 1894 - 1895 |
| Rev. Sidney K. Perkins | 1899 - 1910 |
| Rev. Frank L. Garfield | 1916 - 1920 |
| Rev. Harry McCready | 1917 - 1918 |
| Rev. Harold G. Booth | 1919 - 1922 |
| Rev. Albert S. Hawkes | 1922 - 1928 |
| Rev. Walter Harold Millinger | 1929 - 1952 |
| Rev. Kenneth Freau | 1953 - 1956 |
| Rev. Clarence A. Clark | 1957 - 1967 |
| Rev Raymond B. Wilbur | 1967 - 1983 |
| Rev. William Inderstrodt | 1985 - 1993 |
| Rev. Dr. Richard Knight | 1995 - |
| Rev. Linda B. Hirst | 1998 - |
