| Ruling Elder | Dates |
| John Harmon (Acting) | August 21, 1749 |
| Richard Milberry | August 21, 1749 |
| Samuel Sewall (Elected) | November 29, 1753 |
| Joseph Holt | November 29, 1753 |
| John Bradbury | November 29, 1753 |
| Abiel Goodwin | February 21, 1754 |
| Samuel Milberry | August 30, 1754 |
| Jonathan Sayward | August 2, 1781 |
| Joseph Simpson | August 2, 1781 |
