| Deacon | Dates |
| John Harmon (Acting) | March 27, 1732 |
| Richard Milberry | 1749 |
| Samuel Sewall | November 29, 1753 |
| Joseph Holt | November 29, 1753 |
| John Bradbury | November 29, 1753 |
| Abiel Goodwin | February 21, 1754 |
| Samuel Milberry (Elected) | February 21, 1754 |
| Jonathan Sayward | February 21, 1754 |
| Joseph Simpson | February 21, 1754 |
| Jeremiah Bragdon | February 21, 1754 |
| Francis Raynes (Acting) | September 22, 1765 - October 7, 1792 |
| Wigglesworth Toppan (Elected) | April 14, 1765 |
| John Sewall | August 30, 1781 |
| John Bradbury | August 30, 1781 |
| Joseph Bragdon | ? - January 6, 1819 |
| David Sewall | June 3, 1819 - October 22, 1825 |
| Nathaniel Freeman | November 4, 1824 - April 30, 1834 |
| Samuel Moody | November 4, 1824 - December 1, 1849 |
| Joseph P Junkins | November 20, 1833 - September, 1877 |
| Caleb Eastman | April 3, 1849 - March 12, 1872 |
| Henry D. Norwood | February 12, 1851 - November 20, 1882 |
| Charles C. Barrell | July 5, 1872 - December 23, 1899 |
| Frank P. Emerson | December 27, 1882 - October 22, 1887 |
| Charles E. Gerrish | February 22, 1888 - December, 1907 |
| John E. Staples | January 3, 1900 - August 11, 1915 |
| Daniel A. Stevens | January 6, 1905 - April 7, 1909 |
| William O. Barrell | January 15, 1910 |
