| Church Treasurer | Dates |
| The Deacons | December 3, 1673 - January 2, 1851 |
| Caleb Eastman | January 2, 1851 - May 12, 1872 |
| Joseph Sewall | June 26, 1872 - April 22, 1892 |
| Charles C. Barrell | December 29, 1892 - December 23, 1899 |
| Martha O. Barrell | January 3, 1900 |
